Notes and reflections on history and education

Student Question: Was the French Revolution the beginning of modern history?

In a very real way, yes. I think it’s important, though, that we understand that the French Revolution was about a lot more than toppling monarchy. For the modern state, in my opinion, nationalism is absolutely necessary. The French Revolution (and then Napoleon) demonstrated nationalism’s tremendous mobilization power. Thus the political class is constantly collectivizing (nationalism is simply one form of ideological collectivization), striving to create a sense of nationhood, to create a mega-tribe. Anthems, pledges, flags, military worship, righteous wars, the creation of national myths (masquerading as history), etc. all cultivate a sense of “nation” which can then be mobilized to achieve their ends on a far greater scale than Louis XVI could ever have done.

The French Revolution demonstrated the power of nationalism—in mobilizing resources, in mobilizing entire populations, in waging war. Liberty, equality, fraternity, yes: but within the framework of the nation-state, and led by the State, whose reach “for the good of the nation” was limitless. This was very different from the American Revolution, which had been more about local self-government—but even in the U.S., the nationalist, French system has come to predominate, while American-style federalism has all but disappeared. The French Revolution was about empowering “the French people” as a “nation”…

…And just like that, a new and awesome (and often deadly) force was unleashed upon the world! Napoleon was the first to grasp it and use it, but many others followed.

As always, these are my two cents—but I’m a champion for honest conversation and civil dialogue, so tell me what you think right here!
Featured image: Louis XVI, King of France, in royal costume, 1779
 

Blog Archive

Media Literacy Challenge #7: The Quiet Majority

If you use social media, this one’s a must: check out The...

Read More

Media Literacy Challenge #6: “Attention budget”

Note the expression, pay attention. You should take this pretty literally. The...

Read More

Media Literacy Challenge #5: “The medium is the message”

Socrates famously worried about the invention of writing for the way it...

Read More

Media Literacy Challenge #4: Emotional reasoning

“The real problem of humanity is the following: we have paleolithic emotions,...

Read More

Media Literacy Challenge #3: Knowing your limits

To be literate with the media, we have to be honest about...

Read More

Media Literacy Challenge #2: Corroboration

In 1983 Stanislav Petrov’s decision to “corroborate” the information his computer was...

Read More

Media Literacy Challenge #1: Lateral reading

The Nomadic Professor’s 2026 Media Literacy Challenge: Read Smarter Online! Twice a...

Read More

What kind of history does the Nomadic Professor do?

Nomadic Professor teaches history as method, not ideology: build knowledge, then master...

Read More

Q&A with The Nomadic Professor: Behind the Scenes on the American History series

With the recent roll-out of the complete American History series by The...

Read More

Whose “Last Frontier”?

How do we explore history without choosing sides? In tackling various angles...

Read More

Instructor/Parent Question: Do your courses center God?

Recently, we received another question from a parent considering our courses for...

Read More

Instructor/Parent Question: Do you teach a whitewashed version of history?

We received the following question this week from someone considering our courses...

Read More

A Suggestion for Improving Student Writing

An excerpt from Nate Noorlander’s recent article on Bookshark’s blog, published 1...

Read More

Media Literacy Is an Essential Skill. Schools Should Teach It That Way

An excerpt from Nate Noorlander’s EducationWeek article, published 12 July, 2024: You can...

Read More

Is Tibet really “an integral part of China”?

The NP’s Answer: I once debated the Chinese ambassador to the U.S....

Read More

One “ping” to rule them all

I was once in a faculty meeting to decide on a coherent...

Read More

Student Question: Was the French Revolution the beginning of modern history?

In a very real way, yes. I think it’s important, though, that...

Read More

Does Homeschool Work? “Sourcing” to cut through the statistical noise

A famous study from 1999 by Lawrence M. Rudner surveyed nearly 21,000...

Read More

Parent Question: “Will this course make my child proud of her country?”

We regularly get questions about the slant of our history courses; these...

Read More

Student Question: “Did World War II End the Great Depression?”

According to conventional wisdom, World War II ended the Depression, but there...

Read More

Sign up now for The Nomadic Professor’s newsletter to unlock 9 free research tools. Also receive course updates, learning tips, and exclusive offers!

The Nomadic Newsletter

Sign up now for The Nomadic Professor’s newsletter to unlock 9 free research tools. Also receive course updates, learning tips, and exclusive offers!

Purchase: Bulk Discounts

Number of seats
Discount
Purchase per seat
1
$249
2–4
–25%
$186.75
5–9
–30%
$174.30
10–19
–35%
$161.85
20+
–40%
$149.40

Subscription: Bulk Discounts

Number of seats
Discount
Subscription per seat
1
$30 / month
2–4
–25%
$22.50 / month
5–9
–30%
$21 / month
10–19
–35%
$19.50 / month
20+
–40%
$18 / month

Comments? Corrections? Questions? Exceptional content? Whatever it may be, we’d appreciate you getting in touch.

Reach out to The Nomadic Professor!

Comments? Corrections? Questions? Exceptional content? Whatever it may be, we’d appreciate you getting in touch.

Free Course Previews

Sign up now for free access to sample sessions of The Nomadic Professor’s courses!